Search

COMMENTARY
FINANCIAL SERVICES | Contributed Content, Singapore
Published: 21 Jan 11
2388 views


Is FIDReC fair?

Consumers depend on Fidrec, the Financial Industry Disputes Resolution Centre, and its job is to mediate disputes between customers and financial institutions.

But is it fair?

Fidrec is somewhat of a monopoly since consumers with a financial dispute have almost nowhere else to turn. The Small Claims Tribunal does not hear financial cases. One can take a case to the courts -- even after losing at Fidrec – but it’s expensive. Costs can easily exceed the damages sought. Contrary to popular perception, Fidrec is not a government body. It is a limited liability company, registered in 2005 and listing over 400 “subscribers” on its web site. All are financial institutions like banks, brokers, insurers and financial planners. Most prominent are the 130 banks.

Fidrec hires, fires and reviews the performance of its adjudicators. It also pays their salaries, which come primarily from the financial institutions. They provided start-up capital and pay $500 per case, while plaintiffs must pay only $50.

On the one hand, the lower cost benefits small investors. On the other hand, it may hurt them as well since Fidrec relies on the financial institutions -- who are defendants -- for its financial survival. Does this introduce a subtle bias at Fidrec in favour of the hand that feeds it?

Some of the adjudicators are retired judges and Fidrec’s web site shows that most who heard structured product cases are from big law firms.

Lamb vs wolf negotiations
How many of these law firms have financial institutions as clients or potential clients? How many if any have excused themselves because of actual or potential conflicts? These key questions have never been addressed.

Fidrec’s most well-known cases involved structured products like Lehman Brothers’ Minibonds and DBS’s High Notes 5. Those and all other cases require that plaintiffs make an effort to resolve their complaint with the financial institution before bringing it to Fidrec. It sounds reasonable but presents two problems:

First, it is unusual for a plaintiff to turn over all his evidence to the defendant and get nothing in return. The financial institutions can use the evidence against the plaintiff if the case eventually goes to Fidrec or the courts.

Second, a financial institution, like a bank, would receive a complaint from a customer and then review the customer’s file. It would look at the bank’s total relation with the customer including loans, deposits, investments and the length of time they have been a customer.

If it’s a highly profitable relationship, the bank may find it worthwhile to offer a generous settlement to keep the client. If it’s not, the plaintiff has less bargaining power and may receive less compensation, if any. This makes sense from the bank’s perspective. From the client’s point of view, it could help or hurt but it has nothing to do with the merits of the case. It favours the rich and well connected. It hurts the less affluent.

A second problem is consistency. Courts, for example, are transparent. In contrast, Fidrec requires that its plaintiffs sign a declaration not to disclose anything about the case’s proceedings or its outcome.

Other arbitration cases (non-Fidrec) may have non-disclose clauses, but these are agreed to by both sides. They are not gag orders imposed by an arbitrator, which happens to be a private limited company owned by the defendant. Common law relies on precedents for fairness and consistency. They make it likely that similar cases will be settled similarly. It is hard to establish precedents, however, without knowing the outcomes of cases and no Fidrec case is publicly available.

Defendants are large financial institutions with a legal staff and a history of how similar cases were adjudicated or settled by their own firm.

It is a powerful advantage and gives the financial institution at least a partial history of precedents plus expert advice on how to interpret them.

 

Larry Haverkamp, Finanicial columnist and adjunct faculty in Finance, Economics and Statistics at SMU
 

The views expressed in this column are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect this publication's view, and this article is not edited by Singapore Business Review. The author was not remunerated for this article.



Sign up for our newsletter

 

Do you know more about this story? Contact us anonymously through this link.

Click here to learn about advertising, content sponsorship, events & rountables, custom media solutions, whitepaper writing, sales leads or eDM opportunities with us.

To get a media kit and information on advertising or sponsoring click here.

Tags: is FIDReC fair, Financial Industry Disputes Resolution Centre, financial dispute

CO-WRITTEN ARTICLES & SPONSOR CONTENT ››

Professor Stephen Brammer from the Birmingham Business School says up to 50% of market value is at stake.
310 views

LATEST FINANCIAL SERVICES JOBS »
  • No jobs posted on this category.
PRINT ISSUE »

Subscribe Now
Trains, planes, automobiles and drones

30 views

As goes Hong Kong, so goes Singapore?

354 views

Office property shows no signs of a slowdown

93 views

MOST READ EXCLUSIVES

Singapore's 10 most successful 40 and under hotel managers

Singapore\'s 10 most successful 40 and under hotel managers

Find out who's who in the hotel industry.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
12 Mar 2014 | 54806 views
 

Take an exclusive tour at TripAdvisor's 6,000 sq ft Singapore headquarters

Take an exclusive tour at TripAdvisor\'s 6,000 sq ft Singapore headquarters

It's like having a road trip while at work.

by CARMINA JARIEL
5 Feb 2014 | 19863 views

Singapore's 6 hot new restaurants in April

Singapore\'s 6 hot new restaurants in April

Warm your belly with these top picks.

by STAFF REPORTER
1 Apr 2014 | 19014 views
 

Singapore's top six Valentine’s Day hotels

Singapore\'s top six Valentine’s Day hotels

Ready to pop the question?

by KRISANA GALLEZO
29 Jan 2014 | 17588 views

Singapore's 6 hot new restaurants in February

Singapore\'s 6 hot new restaurants in February

Warm your belly with these picks.

by STAFF REPORTER
27 Feb 2014 | 16125 views
 

Singapore's 6 hot new restaurants in March

Singapore\'s 6 hot new restaurants in March

Get a taste of NYC's eclectic undergound dining.

by STAFF REPORTER
18 Mar 2014 | 13970 views

StarHub's corporate office is so awesome it has its own theatre exclusive to staff

StarHub\'s corporate office is so awesome it has its own theatre exclusive to staff

Check out its other facilities with these pictures.

by STAFF REPORTER
3 Mar 2014 | 9098 views
 

See how FireEye's Singapore headquarters could make hackers scared out of their wits

See how FireEye\'s Singapore headquarters could make hackers scared out of their wits

It's Singapore's threat intelligence hub.

by CARMINA JARIEL
21 Jan 2014 | 7719 views

Should everyone be happy with falling private home prices?

Should everyone be happy with falling private home prices?

And will the cooling measures be relaxed by 2015?

by STAFF REPORTER
9 Apr 2014 | 5801 views
 

Why are office rents suddenly the hottest topic in the property market?

Why are office rents suddenly the hottest topic in the property market?

Everyone has been buzzing about it.

by STAFF REPORTER
26 Mar 2014 | 5398 views

What could make 2014 a disappointing year for Singapore REITs?

What could make 2014 a disappointing year for Singapore REITs?

SREITs are in for a triple whammy.

by KAREN MESINA
22 Jan 2014 | 5190 views
 

Parco Marina Bay at Millenia Walk shuts down on 24 February

Parco Marina Bay at Millenia Walk shuts down on 24 February

Let’s call it a day, says management.

by CARMINA JARIEL
12 Feb 2014 | 4450 views

Find out how this 2-storey gallery-hostel in Singapore is painting the town red

Find out how this 2-storey gallery-hostel in Singapore is painting the town red

It has 18 rooms with 100 beds.

by STAFF REPORTER
27 Feb 2014 | 3823 views
 

Is Singapore's property market still haunted by liquidity nightmares?

Is Singapore\'s property market still haunted by liquidity nightmares?

Analysts are still unimpressed.

by STAFF REPORTER
5 Feb 2014 | 3166 views

Guess where cash-rich shoppers splurged their money over CNY period

Guess where cash-rich shoppers splurged their money over CNY period

Shop 'til you get tracked.

by STAFF REPORTER
14 Feb 2014 | 3137 views
 

Singapore Wine Vault's $200m facility slated to launch in 3Q

Singapore Wine Vault\'s $200m facility slated to launch in 3Q

It can house over 10 million bottles.

by STAFF REPORTER
5 Mar 2014 | 2965 views

How disappointing were the January home sales, really?

How disappointing were the January home sales, really?

Analysts are still keeping their hopes up for next month.

by STAFF REPORTER
19 Feb 2014 | 2541 views
 

Find out how this startup plans to beat Singapore’s skyrocketing car prices

Find out how this startup plans to beat Singapore’s skyrocketing car prices

It’s speeding up its Asian expansion.

by STAFF REPORTER
5 Mar 2014 | 2276 views

Singapore is world's most expensive city—but only for expats

Singapore is world\'s most expensive city—but only for expats

Is The Lion City still affordable to ordinary Singaporeans?

by STAFF REPORTER
6 Mar 2014 | 2128 views
 

SingTel, StarHub stuck in a tight tug-of-war over 2014 World Cup broadcast rights

SingTel, StarHub stuck in a tight tug-of-war over 2014 World Cup broadcast rights

Negotiations are challenging, said StarHub.

by STAFF REPORTER
17 Feb 2014 | 2039 views

Buckle up: Car sharing firms gain ground in Singapore

Buckle up: Car sharing firms gain ground in Singapore

Should car retailers be scared?

by CARMINA JARIEL
10 Feb 2014 | 1902 views
 

Singaporeans mine gold in ‘second hand economy’ amidst skyrocketing cost of living

Singaporeans mine gold in ‘second hand economy’ amidst skyrocketing cost of living

8 in 10 Singaporeans admit to purchasing pre-owned goods.

by CARMINA JARIEL
28 Mar 2014 | 1793 views

Singapore hoteliers saw flat Chinese New Year

Singapore hoteliers saw flat Chinese New Year

Business was challenging, they said.

by STAFF REPORTER
5 Feb 2014 | 1702 views
 

What does Singapore's 6.2% industrial production growth imply for the rest of 2014?

What does Singapore\'s 6.2% industrial production growth imply for the rest of 2014?

Analysts are delighted by it.

by STAFF REPORTER
29 Jan 2014 | 1470 views

How a horrible renovation experience inspired Kluje to build a home renovation empire

How a horrible renovation experience inspired Kluje to build a home renovation empire

Over 400 accounts created in its first 2 months.

by CARMINA JARIEL
5 Feb 2014 | 1378 views
 

Will Singapore banks break hearts with bad results on Valentine's Day?

Will Singapore banks break hearts with bad results on Valentine\'s Day?

Especially with the easing of debt servicing burden.

by STAFF REPORTER
12 Feb 2014 | 1322 views

Singapore's most followed Google+ personality joins local startup

Singapore\'s most followed Google+ personality joins local startup

Check out how "SuperMommy" plans to take Tickled Media into another level.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
3 Apr 2014 | 1318 views
 

See how Zalora's 24-hour online ad campaign boosts Singapore's music scene

See how Zalora\'s 24-hour online ad campaign boosts Singapore\'s music scene

It collaborated with local singer-songwriters.

by STAFF REPORTER
22 Jan 2014 | 1304 views

See how this startup lets you create free listings in less than 30 seconds

See how this startup lets you create free listings in less than 30 seconds

Forget about Craiglist or Gumtree.

by STAFF REPORTER
19 Feb 2014 | 1203 views
 

Self-storage firms find silver lining in Singapore's space crisis

Self-storage firms find silver lining in Singapore\'s space crisis

Less space, more money.

by CARMINA JARIEL
19 Feb 2014 | 1150 views
close Don't Show Again

STAY INFORMED! Get our free weekly newsletter