Search

COMMENTARY
FINANCIAL SERVICES | Contributed Content, Singapore
Published: 21 Jan 11
3207 views


Is FIDReC fair?

Consumers depend on Fidrec, the Financial Industry Disputes Resolution Centre, and its job is to mediate disputes between customers and financial institutions.

But is it fair?

Fidrec is somewhat of a monopoly since consumers with a financial dispute have almost nowhere else to turn. The Small Claims Tribunal does not hear financial cases. One can take a case to the courts -- even after losing at Fidrec – but it’s expensive. Costs can easily exceed the damages sought. Contrary to popular perception, Fidrec is not a government body. It is a limited liability company, registered in 2005 and listing over 400 “subscribers” on its web site. All are financial institutions like banks, brokers, insurers and financial planners. Most prominent are the 130 banks.

Fidrec hires, fires and reviews the performance of its adjudicators. It also pays their salaries, which come primarily from the financial institutions. They provided start-up capital and pay $500 per case, while plaintiffs must pay only $50.

On the one hand, the lower cost benefits small investors. On the other hand, it may hurt them as well since Fidrec relies on the financial institutions -- who are defendants -- for its financial survival. Does this introduce a subtle bias at Fidrec in favour of the hand that feeds it?

Some of the adjudicators are retired judges and Fidrec’s web site shows that most who heard structured product cases are from big law firms.

Lamb vs wolf negotiations
How many of these law firms have financial institutions as clients or potential clients? How many if any have excused themselves because of actual or potential conflicts? These key questions have never been addressed.

Fidrec’s most well-known cases involved structured products like Lehman Brothers’ Minibonds and DBS’s High Notes 5. Those and all other cases require that plaintiffs make an effort to resolve their complaint with the financial institution before bringing it to Fidrec. It sounds reasonable but presents two problems:

First, it is unusual for a plaintiff to turn over all his evidence to the defendant and get nothing in return. The financial institutions can use the evidence against the plaintiff if the case eventually goes to Fidrec or the courts.

Second, a financial institution, like a bank, would receive a complaint from a customer and then review the customer’s file. It would look at the bank’s total relation with the customer including loans, deposits, investments and the length of time they have been a customer.

If it’s a highly profitable relationship, the bank may find it worthwhile to offer a generous settlement to keep the client. If it’s not, the plaintiff has less bargaining power and may receive less compensation, if any. This makes sense from the bank’s perspective. From the client’s point of view, it could help or hurt but it has nothing to do with the merits of the case. It favours the rich and well connected. It hurts the less affluent.

A second problem is consistency. Courts, for example, are transparent. In contrast, Fidrec requires that its plaintiffs sign a declaration not to disclose anything about the case’s proceedings or its outcome.

Other arbitration cases (non-Fidrec) may have non-disclose clauses, but these are agreed to by both sides. They are not gag orders imposed by an arbitrator, which happens to be a private limited company owned by the defendant. Common law relies on precedents for fairness and consistency. They make it likely that similar cases will be settled similarly. It is hard to establish precedents, however, without knowing the outcomes of cases and no Fidrec case is publicly available.

Defendants are large financial institutions with a legal staff and a history of how similar cases were adjudicated or settled by their own firm.

It is a powerful advantage and gives the financial institution at least a partial history of precedents plus expert advice on how to interpret them.

 

Larry Haverkamp, Finanicial columnist and adjunct faculty in Finance, Economics and Statistics at SMU
 

The views expressed in this column are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect this publication's view, and this article is not edited by Singapore Business Review. The author was not remunerated for this article.



Sign up for our newsletter

 

Do you know more about this story? Contact us anonymously through this link.

Click here to learn about advertising, content sponsorship, events & rountables, custom media solutions, whitepaper writing, sales leads or eDM opportunities with us.

To get a media kit and information on advertising or sponsoring click here.

Tags: is FIDReC fair, Financial Industry Disputes Resolution Centre, financial dispute

LATEST FINANCIAL SERVICES JOBS »
PRINT ISSUE »

Subscribe Now
What factors are keeping expats rooted in Singapore?

989 views

What factors are keeping expats rooted in Singapore?

576 views

Can Asian private equity outgrow the west?

245 views

MOST READ EXCLUSIVES

16 items that are a tad cheaper in Singapore than in Hong Kong

16 items that are a tad cheaper in Singapore than in Hong Kong

Coffee lovers need not go farther for a cheaper cup of cappuccino.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
20 Mar 2015 | 99148 views
 

The 10 richest Singaporeans

The 10 richest Singaporeans

Altogether, their total amount of wealth dropped by 20% to US$32.5 billion.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
13 Apr 2015 | 96518 views

Singapore’s 8 hottest 40 and under hotel chefs

Singapore’s 8 hottest 40 and under hotel chefs

Check out and be inspired from their humble beginnings before rising the ranks.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
27 Mar 2015 | 13399 views
 

Chow Tai Fook opens second store in Singapore

Chow Tai Fook opens second store in Singapore

It's a 1,000-square feet new jewellery shop on Orchard Road.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
26 Feb 2015 | 12239 views

This is a woman’s world: CRIB launches Singapore’s first business and lifestyle incubator for women

This is a woman’s world: CRIB launches Singapore’s first business and lifestyle incubator for women

Find out what the three key platforms of CRIB are.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
10 Mar 2015 | 8161 views
 

The New Black hits Singapore with rarest green coffee

The New Black hits Singapore with rarest green coffee

It also boasts of its Impossible Collection curated by the ‘world’s rockstar roasters'.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
5 Mar 2015 | 4773 views

Too many business cards? Why don’t you try Sansan’s business card management service?

Too many business cards? Why don’t you try Sansan’s business card management service?

After Singapore, this contract management company plans to expand in the APAC region.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
12 Feb 2015 | 4385 views
 

Check out this integrated office cum lab of Friesland Campina in Singapore

Check out this integrated office cum lab of Friesland Campina in Singapore

A curved glass wall resulted in a 90% open-plan office.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
17 Feb 2015 | 4371 views

Spencer Ogden gets funky with its newest trademark space in Singapore

Spencer Ogden gets funky with its newest trademark space in Singapore

The company invested over $1M to make this signature office possible.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
5 Feb 2015 | 3498 views
 

Want to be hands-on with your ideal home setting?

Want to be hands-on with your ideal home setting?

Commune is opening an Experience Centre for meticulous homeowners.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
23 Mar 2015 | 2905 views

Office in the sky: How’s having a meeting in the clouds?

Office in the sky: How’s having a meeting in the clouds?

Check out ACL Asia Pacific’s Cumulonimbus, Altostratus and Cirrus rooms.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
1 Apr 2015 | 2774 views
 

Lazada Singapore CEO Martell Hardenberg talks about his “Happy Customer” philosophy

Lazada Singapore CEO Martell Hardenberg talks about his “Happy Customer” philosophy

Find out what other goals the 27-year-old has for the company.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
27 Mar 2015 | 2376 views

LawCanvas saves the day: Easy legal documents in under a minute

LawCanvas saves the day: Easy legal documents in under a minute

The founders revolutionized the legal industry despite having different backgrounds.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
2 Mar 2015 | 2311 views
 

Take a look inside INSEAD’s $55m leadership development centre in Singapore

Take a look inside INSEAD’s $55m leadership development centre in Singapore

It marks the fulfillment of a vision too ambitious to achieve 15 years ago.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
1 Apr 2015 | 2307 views

PocketMath makes buying mobile ad impressions easier

PocketMath makes buying mobile ad impressions easier

It integrates over 20 ad exchanges and offers over 20B impressions a day.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
9 Feb 2015 | 1771 views
 

#OnTheContrary campaign reveals the ‘real struggles’ of entrepreneurs

#OnTheContrary campaign reveals the ‘real struggles’ of entrepreneurs

Rags to riches stories are fabulous, but here’s the real deal.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
27 Mar 2015 | 1019 views

Find out what it’s like going into business with your in-law

Find out what it’s like going into business with your in-law

A young entrepreneur teamed up with his father-in-law to redefine home entertainment needs.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
27 Mar 2015 | 776 views
 

What is the future of the sports business in Singapore?

What is the future of the sports business in Singapore?

Can a new billion-dollar stadium give Singapore the edge it needs to compete for world-class sporting events?

by STAFF REPORTER
20 Mar 2015 | 694 views

Fragrance Du Bois to launch a new scent this year

Fragrance Du Bois to launch a new scent this year

Also, check out its pop-up boutique at TANGS Orchard open until April 26.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
17 Apr 2015 | 415 views
 
close Don't Show Again

STAY INFORMED! Get our free weekly newsletter