Search

COMMENTARY
HR & EDUCATION | Contributed Content, Singapore
Published: 02 Jan 12
1310 views


Are your performance measures costing you money?

Performance measures and key performance indicators (KPIs) are a powerful part of a Singapore manager’s tool kit but when applied inappropriately their cost can actually outweigh the benefit they provide. Are you using your performance measures appropriately or are they costing you money?

Performance measurement is important in any business. An old adage, which still stands true today is ‘you can’t improve what you don’t measure.’ By informing us of where we are at, performance measures play several key roles. They:

- Provide control: management can measure current levels of activity and see where improvements can be made
- Enable decision-making: they provide important information and visibility across the organisation, helping executives make timely and effective decisions
- Provide direction: performance measures link activities to the business strategy and provide employees at all levels with information about what is required to drive the organisation towards its aims

A well-designed and well-executed performance measurement process can drive a company towards its strategic objectives and provide that competitive edge. Unfortunately, there are a number of pitfalls awaiting the unwary organisation, and in the worst-case scenario, the costs associated with establishing and generating performance measures can even outweigh the benefits.

Some of the most common issues with performance measurement are:

1. Lack of alignment across the organisation
All performance measures need to be for the overall improvement of the organisation and should not drive conflicting behaviour. Within some organisations departments and individuals find themselves in conflict, as the targets they have been set have a negative impact elsewhere. For example, a product development group may be measured against number of production trials, but production trials inevitably have an adverse impact on plant uptime, and maximising uptime could be the performance measure for the manufacturing department. This can cause conflict between the two departments and a sub-optimal outcome for the organisation.

2. Gaps in the measures applied through the organisation hierarchy
A good test to see if an organisation is using performance measures to effectively deploy and drive strategy, is to ask an individual at the lowest level in the organisational hierarchy to explain how the performance measures used for their role or the processes that they work on, link to the achievement of the overall business strategy.

For example, a KPI for completion of planned maintenance activities. This should have an effect on machine availability and thus on master production schedule performance, and subsequently on the ability to deliver in full on time (DIFOT), which is fundamental for achieving a business strategy of becoming a reliable business partner.

This example illustrates the cause-effect relationship between the measures applied at the different levels of hierarchy within the organisation. Understanding how the different measures affect one another helps to highlight any gaps in strategy and can be useful in identifying improvement activity, particularly if higher level measures aren’t achieving their targets. Providing visibility throughout the organisation also allows different departments and individuals to see how they contribute to the success of the business, giving them more incentive to do well and consequently greater job satisfaction.

3. Not being used to drive improvement
Many organisations devote considerable time and resource to the preparation of performance data and brightly coloured charts and presentations each month, but not all of them do anything with the outcome. It’s no use displaying performance measures on the wall if they don’t provoke any action – in this case some attractive wallpaper will do the same job, for considerably less cost! A significant effort is required to measure performance properly and to get full value, organisations need to include targets and control limits to drive better performance going forwards. Performance levels should be analysed and in the event targets are not being achieved root cause analysis undertaken to understand why, and then corrective actions agreed and monitored. Improvement without measurement is impossible, but measurement that is not used to drive improvement is a waste in itself.

Stuart Harman, Partner, Oliver Wight 

The views expressed in this column are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect this publication's view, and this article is not edited by Singapore Business Review. The author was not remunerated for this article.



Sign up for our newsletter

 

Do you know more about this story? Contact us anonymously through this link.

Click here to learn about advertising, content sponsorship, events & rountables, custom media solutions, whitepaper writing, sales leads or eDM opportunities with us.

To get a media kit and information on advertising or sponsoring click here.

Tags: Stuart Harman, Are your performance measures costing you money, Oliver Wight

CO-WRITTEN ARTICLES & SPONSOR CONTENT ››

Professor Stephen Brammer from the Birmingham Business School says up to 50% of market value is at stake.
193 views

LATEST HR & EDUCATION JOBS »
PRINT ISSUE »

Subscribe Now
Trains, planes, automobiles and drones

22 views

As goes Hong Kong, so goes Singapore?

317 views

Office property shows no signs of a slowdown

83 views

MOST READ EXCLUSIVES

Singapore's 10 most successful 40 and under hotel managers

Singapore\'s 10 most successful 40 and under hotel managers

Find out who's who in the hotel industry.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
12 Mar 2014 | 52833 views
 

Take an exclusive tour at TripAdvisor's 6,000 sq ft Singapore headquarters

Take an exclusive tour at TripAdvisor\'s 6,000 sq ft Singapore headquarters

It's like having a road trip while at work.

by CARMINA JARIEL
5 Feb 2014 | 19429 views

Singapore's top six Valentine’s Day hotels

Singapore\'s top six Valentine’s Day hotels

Ready to pop the question?

by KRISANA GALLEZO
29 Jan 2014 | 17462 views
 

Singapore's 6 hot new restaurants in February

Singapore\'s 6 hot new restaurants in February

Warm your belly with these picks.

by STAFF REPORTER
27 Feb 2014 | 15902 views

Singapore's 6 hot new restaurants in April

Singapore\'s 6 hot new restaurants in April

Warm your belly with these top picks.

by STAFF REPORTER
1 Apr 2014 | 15367 views
 

Singapore's 6 hot new restaurants in March

Singapore\'s 6 hot new restaurants in March

Get a taste of NYC's eclectic undergound dining.

by STAFF REPORTER
18 Mar 2014 | 13513 views

StarHub's corporate office is so awesome it has its own theatre exclusive to staff

StarHub\'s corporate office is so awesome it has its own theatre exclusive to staff

Check out its other facilities with these pictures.

by STAFF REPORTER
3 Mar 2014 | 8619 views
 

See how FireEye's Singapore headquarters could make hackers scared out of their wits

See how FireEye\'s Singapore headquarters could make hackers scared out of their wits

It's Singapore's threat intelligence hub.

by CARMINA JARIEL
21 Jan 2014 | 7499 views

Why are office rents suddenly the hottest topic in the property market?

Why are office rents suddenly the hottest topic in the property market?

Everyone has been buzzing about it.

by STAFF REPORTER
26 Mar 2014 | 5299 views
 

What could make 2014 a disappointing year for Singapore REITs?

What could make 2014 a disappointing year for Singapore REITs?

SREITs are in for a triple whammy.

by KAREN MESINA
22 Jan 2014 | 5021 views

Parco Marina Bay at Millenia Walk shuts down on 24 February

Parco Marina Bay at Millenia Walk shuts down on 24 February

Let’s call it a day, says management.

by CARMINA JARIEL
12 Feb 2014 | 4316 views
 

Find out how this 2-storey gallery-hostel in Singapore is painting the town red

Find out how this 2-storey gallery-hostel in Singapore is painting the town red

It has 18 rooms with 100 beds.

by STAFF REPORTER
27 Feb 2014 | 3713 views

Is Singapore's property market still haunted by liquidity nightmares?

Is Singapore\'s property market still haunted by liquidity nightmares?

Analysts are still unimpressed.

by STAFF REPORTER
5 Feb 2014 | 3107 views
 

Guess where cash-rich shoppers splurged their money over CNY period

Guess where cash-rich shoppers splurged their money over CNY period

Shop 'til you get tracked.

by STAFF REPORTER
14 Feb 2014 | 3089 views

Singapore Wine Vault's $200m facility slated to launch in 3Q

Singapore Wine Vault\'s $200m facility slated to launch in 3Q

It can house over 10 million bottles.

by STAFF REPORTER
5 Mar 2014 | 2863 views
 

How disappointing were the January home sales, really?

How disappointing were the January home sales, really?

Analysts are still keeping their hopes up for next month.

by STAFF REPORTER
19 Feb 2014 | 2514 views

Find out how this startup plans to beat Singapore’s skyrocketing car prices

Find out how this startup plans to beat Singapore’s skyrocketing car prices

It’s speeding up its Asian expansion.

by STAFF REPORTER
5 Mar 2014 | 2205 views
 

SingTel, StarHub stuck in a tight tug-of-war over 2014 World Cup broadcast rights

SingTel, StarHub stuck in a tight tug-of-war over 2014 World Cup broadcast rights

Negotiations are challenging, said StarHub.

by STAFF REPORTER
17 Feb 2014 | 1987 views

Buckle up: Car sharing firms gain ground in Singapore

Buckle up: Car sharing firms gain ground in Singapore

Should car retailers be scared?

by CARMINA JARIEL
10 Feb 2014 | 1872 views
 

Singapore is world's most expensive city—but only for expats

Singapore is world\'s most expensive city—but only for expats

Is The Lion City still affordable to ordinary Singaporeans?

by STAFF REPORTER
6 Mar 2014 | 1835 views

Singapore hoteliers saw flat Chinese New Year

Singapore hoteliers saw flat Chinese New Year

Business was challenging, they said.

by STAFF REPORTER
5 Feb 2014 | 1681 views
 

Singaporeans mine gold in ‘second hand economy’ amidst skyrocketing cost of living

Singaporeans mine gold in ‘second hand economy’ amidst skyrocketing cost of living

8 in 10 Singaporeans admit to purchasing pre-owned goods.

by CARMINA JARIEL
28 Mar 2014 | 1556 views

What does Singapore's 6.2% industrial production growth imply for the rest of 2014?

What does Singapore\'s 6.2% industrial production growth imply for the rest of 2014?

Analysts are delighted by it.

by STAFF REPORTER
29 Jan 2014 | 1396 views
 

How a horrible renovation experience inspired Kluje to build a home renovation empire

How a horrible renovation experience inspired Kluje to build a home renovation empire

Over 400 accounts created in its first 2 months.

by CARMINA JARIEL
5 Feb 2014 | 1339 views

Will Singapore banks break hearts with bad results on Valentine's Day?

Will Singapore banks break hearts with bad results on Valentine\'s Day?

Especially with the easing of debt servicing burden.

by STAFF REPORTER
12 Feb 2014 | 1303 views
 

See how Zalora's 24-hour online ad campaign boosts Singapore's music scene

See how Zalora\'s 24-hour online ad campaign boosts Singapore\'s music scene

It collaborated with local singer-songwriters.

by STAFF REPORTER
22 Jan 2014 | 1275 views

See how this startup lets you create free listings in less than 30 seconds

See how this startup lets you create free listings in less than 30 seconds

Forget about Craiglist or Gumtree.

by STAFF REPORTER
19 Feb 2014 | 1169 views
 

Self-storage firms find silver lining in Singapore's space crisis

Self-storage firms find silver lining in Singapore\'s space crisis

Less space, more money.

by CARMINA JARIEL
19 Feb 2014 | 1091 views

Find out how Paktor helps you find 'the one' in just 15 seconds

Find out how Paktor helps you find \'the one\' in just 15 seconds

Yes, Valentine's Day came early.

by STAFF REPORTER
28 Jan 2014 | 1069 views
 

Singapore's most followed Google+ personality joins local startup

Singapore\'s most followed Google+ personality joins local startup

Check out how "SuperMommy" plans to take Tickled Media into another level.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
3 Apr 2014 | 1061 views
close Don't Show Again

STAY INFORMED! Get our free weekly newsletter