Search

COMMENTARY
HR & EDUCATION | Contributed Content, Singapore
Published: 02 Jan 12
1340 views


Are your performance measures costing you money?

Performance measures and key performance indicators (KPIs) are a powerful part of a Singapore manager’s tool kit but when applied inappropriately their cost can actually outweigh the benefit they provide. Are you using your performance measures appropriately or are they costing you money?

Performance measurement is important in any business. An old adage, which still stands true today is ‘you can’t improve what you don’t measure.’ By informing us of where we are at, performance measures play several key roles. They:

- Provide control: management can measure current levels of activity and see where improvements can be made
- Enable decision-making: they provide important information and visibility across the organisation, helping executives make timely and effective decisions
- Provide direction: performance measures link activities to the business strategy and provide employees at all levels with information about what is required to drive the organisation towards its aims

A well-designed and well-executed performance measurement process can drive a company towards its strategic objectives and provide that competitive edge. Unfortunately, there are a number of pitfalls awaiting the unwary organisation, and in the worst-case scenario, the costs associated with establishing and generating performance measures can even outweigh the benefits.

Some of the most common issues with performance measurement are:

1. Lack of alignment across the organisation
All performance measures need to be for the overall improvement of the organisation and should not drive conflicting behaviour. Within some organisations departments and individuals find themselves in conflict, as the targets they have been set have a negative impact elsewhere. For example, a product development group may be measured against number of production trials, but production trials inevitably have an adverse impact on plant uptime, and maximising uptime could be the performance measure for the manufacturing department. This can cause conflict between the two departments and a sub-optimal outcome for the organisation.

2. Gaps in the measures applied through the organisation hierarchy
A good test to see if an organisation is using performance measures to effectively deploy and drive strategy, is to ask an individual at the lowest level in the organisational hierarchy to explain how the performance measures used for their role or the processes that they work on, link to the achievement of the overall business strategy.

For example, a KPI for completion of planned maintenance activities. This should have an effect on machine availability and thus on master production schedule performance, and subsequently on the ability to deliver in full on time (DIFOT), which is fundamental for achieving a business strategy of becoming a reliable business partner.

This example illustrates the cause-effect relationship between the measures applied at the different levels of hierarchy within the organisation. Understanding how the different measures affect one another helps to highlight any gaps in strategy and can be useful in identifying improvement activity, particularly if higher level measures aren’t achieving their targets. Providing visibility throughout the organisation also allows different departments and individuals to see how they contribute to the success of the business, giving them more incentive to do well and consequently greater job satisfaction.

3. Not being used to drive improvement
Many organisations devote considerable time and resource to the preparation of performance data and brightly coloured charts and presentations each month, but not all of them do anything with the outcome. It’s no use displaying performance measures on the wall if they don’t provoke any action – in this case some attractive wallpaper will do the same job, for considerably less cost! A significant effort is required to measure performance properly and to get full value, organisations need to include targets and control limits to drive better performance going forwards. Performance levels should be analysed and in the event targets are not being achieved root cause analysis undertaken to understand why, and then corrective actions agreed and monitored. Improvement without measurement is impossible, but measurement that is not used to drive improvement is a waste in itself.

Stuart Harman, Partner, Oliver Wight 

The views expressed in this column are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect this publication's view, and this article is not edited by Singapore Business Review. The author was not remunerated for this article.



Sign up for our newsletter

 

Do you know more about this story? Contact us anonymously through this link.

Click here to learn about advertising, content sponsorship, events & rountables, custom media solutions, whitepaper writing, sales leads or eDM opportunities with us.

To get a media kit and information on advertising or sponsoring click here.

Tags: Stuart Harman, Are your performance measures costing you money, Oliver Wight

CO-WRITTEN ARTICLES & SPONSOR CONTENT ››

Supply chain and logistics management business explained.
16 views

Global ethernet services market headed for $50 bn by 2015.
285 views

From humble beginnings to a 50,000 sqft property.
86 views

Find out why 2014 is the best time for you to enter Forex.
143 views

One-stop convention solution is here.
611 views

Its programmes ready graduates for real-world challenges.
136 views

Meet the man behind Singapore’s only automobile manufacturer.
379 views

Why is a holistic curriculum still important?
244 views

Fully furnished, hassle-free office experience.
164 views

Instead of burying their heads in books or articles on effective marketing techniques, advertising executives may want to sit back, relax and surf the web once in a while.
384 views

LATEST HR & EDUCATION JOBS »
PRINT ISSUE »

Subscribe Now
Trains, planes, automobiles and drones

132 views

As goes Hong Kong, so goes Singapore?

1106 views

Office property shows no signs of a slowdown

289 views

MOST READ EXCLUSIVES

Singapore’s 20 hotels with most expensive buffet lunches

Singapore’s 20 hotels with most expensive buffet lunches

What is for lunch?

by KRISANA GALLEZO
6 Jun 2014 | 176864 views
 

Singapore’s 20 most expensive hotel suites

Singapore’s 20 most expensive hotel suites

Guess which tops the list at S$20,000 a night.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
30 May 2014 | 148611 views

Singapore’s 18 MBA programmes under $30,000

Singapore’s 18 MBA programmes under $30,000

The cheapest is at SGD15,000.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
17 Jun 2014 | 106996 views
 

9 most expensive credit cards in Singapore

9 most expensive credit cards in Singapore

The most premium requires $150,000 annual income.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
21 Jul 2014 | 96539 views

Singapore’s 10 most expensive MBA Programmes

Singapore’s 10 most expensive MBA Programmes

The costliest is being offered at over $100,000.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
26 Jun 2014 | 80004 views
 

Singapore’s 10 hottest 40 and under restaurateurs

Singapore’s 10 hottest 40 and under restaurateurs

The list includes a restaurateur as young as 27.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
3 Jul 2014 | 38253 views

Singapore's 7 hot new restaurants in May

Singapore\'s 7 hot new restaurants in May

Have you tried them all?

by KRISANA GALLEZO
5 Jun 2014 | 22974 views
 

Singapore’s 8 hot new restaurants in June

Singapore’s 8 hot new restaurants in June

Have you dropped by to check them out?

by KRISANA GALLEZO
3 Jul 2014 | 22242 views

Korea’s Yoogane to open second outlet in Singapore

Korea’s Yoogane to open second outlet in Singapore

More outlets are soon to come.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
29 May 2014 | 16268 views
 

Pratt & Whitney Singapore office makes you feel like you’re in the outer space

Pratt & Whitney Singapore office makes you feel like you’re in the outer space

Take a sneak peek.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
25 Jun 2014 | 13339 views

Singapore's 8 hot new restaurants in July

Singapore\'s 8 hot new restaurants in July

More Singapore openings from famous restaurants in Asia.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
4 Aug 2014 | 11780 views
 

Towers Watson Singapore’s Spa Room allows staff to regenerate during lazy hours

Towers Watson Singapore’s Spa Room allows staff to regenerate during lazy hours

Also, check out awesome photos of redesigned meeting rooms and clubhouse.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
9 Jul 2014 | 10088 views

Taiwan’s Sufood hit Singapore

Taiwan’s Sufood hit Singapore

Eight more outlets coming in five years.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
12 Jun 2014 | 7288 views
 

Awesome workplace at 501: How's having a meeting while cuddling a teddy bear?

Awesome workplace at 501: How\'s having a meeting while cuddling a teddy bear?

Also check artistically designed in-house locations for video shoots.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
6 Aug 2014 | 6051 views

Check out HSBC’s high-tech flagship branch at Orchard Road

Check out HSBC’s high-tech flagship branch at Orchard Road

It’s digital hub is a star attraction.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
23 Jul 2014 | 4506 views
 

What 3 market leaders can tell you about price comparison sites in Singapore

What 3 market leaders can tell you about price comparison sites in Singapore

Financial price comparison sites face lack of consumer’s confidence.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
10 Jul 2014 | 4063 views

Find out how 3 young men at 20s founded a startup

Find out how 3 young men at 20s founded a startup

At 21, they built a job portal to help young people find their jobs.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
10 Jul 2014 | 3500 views
 

DBS added 1000 more staff in 2013

DBS added 1000 more staff in 2013

It topples UOB to become Singapore's second largest commercial bank.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
22 Jul 2014 | 1856 views

I bet you’ll cry after watching this: Singaporeans say ‘thank you’ to migrant workers

I bet you’ll cry after watching this: Singaporeans say ‘thank you’ to migrant workers

It has been viewed and shared nearly 425,000 times.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
27 Jun 2014 | 1771 views
 

Singapore startup builds world’s first crowdpricing platform

Singapore startup builds world’s first crowdpricing platform

Here’s how you could end up paying less.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
29 May 2014 | 1764 views

Haji Lane welcomes a hippy motorcycle cafe

Haji Lane welcomes a hippy motorcycle cafe

It serves all-day brunches with motorcycle merchandise up for grabs.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
28 Jul 2014 | 1759 views
 

RIP Tiger Mandala: What carrier is next to die?

RIP Tiger Mandala: What carrier is next to die?

See why Singapore based carriers are the least advantaged.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
27 Jun 2014 | 1721 views

Singpost acquires Store House in Hong Kong for $12.2m

Singpost acquires Store House in Hong Kong for $12.2m

Here's how management compares HK's self storage market with Singapore's.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
11 Jul 2014 | 1491 views
 

Might as well say, what the :pluck?

Might as well say, what the :pluck?

Ann Siang Hill and Club Street welcome a new 45-seat dining enclave.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
26 Jun 2014 | 1470 views

The Assembly Ground will choose for you the coffee that best suits you

The Assembly Ground will choose for you  the coffee that best suits you

It’s an Australian concept brought to Singapore.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
18 Jul 2014 | 1402 views
 

KepLand in the spotlight: After Equity Plaza, what's next to sell?

KepLand in the spotlight: After Equity Plaza, what\'s next to sell?

Keppel Land determined to hold its stake in MBFC Tower 3.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
26 Jun 2014 | 1289 views

Take a tour at Potato Head Folk’s whimsical dining enclave

Take a tour at Potato Head Folk’s whimsical dining enclave

Murals on the walls inspired by 1930s children’s books are fascinating.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
10 Jul 2014 | 1274 views
 

See how 99.co plans to pacify exasperated house-hunters in Singapore

See how 99.co plans to pacify exasperated house-hunters in Singapore

Tired of bogus listings?

by CARMINA JARIEL
22 May 2014 | 1258 views

Experience in 3D how your neighborhood will look like if sea levels rise

Experience in 3D how your neighborhood will look like if sea levels rise

This site is hitting almost a million unique visitors already.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
13 Jun 2014 | 1098 views
 

Check out this WhatsApp like program for online chatting

Check out this WhatsApp like program for online chatting

This startup is on its final stages of closing $500,000 fund.

by KRISANA GALLEZO
19 Jun 2014 | 1063 views
close Don't Show Again

STAY INFORMED! Get our free weekly newsletter